Skip to content

ANATOMY OF MURDER is a weekly true crime podcast examining homicide cases and paths to justice for the victims. Former New York City homicide prosecutor and host of Investigation Discovery’s True Conviction, Anna-Sigga Nicolazzi, teams up with Emmy award-winning investigative journalist, and former Deputy Sheriff Scott Weinberger, to take listeners behind the scenes, for an insider’s perspective of compelling homicide cases from around the country. In every episode, listeners will also hear and gain insight from a victim’s family member, the prosecutor, or a member of law enforcement directly involved in the investigation.

urn_aaid_sc_US_6c655e60-3f4f-4afc-bb19-2734657dfb6f;revision=0 (7)
Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-95

Carl & Jackie – Part 2: The Triggermen (Carl Gaimari)

Arson, adultery and a wife under arrest for orchestrating her husband, Carl Gaimari's murder. Investigators try to put everything together?

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-94

Carl & Jackie – Part 1 (Carl Gaimari)

A twisted tale of possible arson, adultery, and the murder of a wealthy commodities trader, Carl Gaimari, starts to unravel.

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-93

The Snake (Krystal Mitchell)

Krystal Mitchell's mother’s quest to locate the man charged with her daughter’s murder spans countries, and now, years.

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-92

The Backwards Case (Jose Ignacio Valdez-Guzman)

How do you investigate a homicide when you don’t have a body, a name, or any evidence of a crime except for one person’s word?

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-91

Day in Court (Rhonda Furmanek)

Rhonda Furmanek is murdered with her young girls in the next room. Her 6-year-old daughter will walk into court more than once.

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-90

Pastor’s Wife (Pauletta Burleson)

A pastor’s wife, Pauletta Burleson, is gunned down. Their relationship, church and family, start to mix in ways no one expected.

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-89

Lovers’ Lane (Robert Farberger & Eva Caudell)

Robert Farberger & Eva Caudell seeks seclusion on a quiet, winter night. A romantic rendezvous becomes a double homicide.

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-88

Wrong Man (Eugene Elliott Dickerson)

Eugene Dickerson is gunned down soon after town’s high school basketball game. An officer plays an unexpected role in solving the mystery.

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-87

Facing Evil (Nekitta Hamilton, Davion Bishop and Faith Bisasor)

A brutal crime scene… three lives lost, Nekitta Hamilton, Davion Bishop and Faith Bisasor… and forensic evidence in question…

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-86

John Doe Duffel Bag (Mohamed Gebeli, Isaac Kadare, Rahmatollah Vahidipour)

Three killings with a mix of gunshot and stab wounds drive hundreds of detectives to hunt down a serial killer. His trademark? A duffel bag.

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-85

Who’s behind the door? (Ginger Hayden)

Two doors — a sliding glass and a closet door — may be the best chances investigators have at finding a killer.

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-84

Pick up the Pieces (Sarah Jeanette Benson)

In this Indiana town, murders are rare, but rumors run rampant. A sheriff nearing retirement sifts through leads to solve a 41-year-old case.

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-83

Clues in the Ceiling (Linda Leon & Esteban Martinez)

A search of a drop ceiling yields a big surprise; its contents may be the very clue needed to catch the killers.

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-82

Tutu (Audrey Scott)

An innocuous card game raises a mom’s suspicions about her daughter, Audrey Scott's boyfriend.

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-81-update

House of Witnesses (Jose Luis Menchaca & Domonique Hernandez)

Body parts and a backyard bbq. Investigators quickly know The Who, but they need to uncover The What.

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-80

Malícia (Alexandria Burgos)

An 18-year-old woman, Alexandria Burgos is murdered at a child’s birthday party.

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-79

Hit and Run? (William “Billy” Brown)

William Brown's roadside death pushes his family to question the crime scene.

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-78

10-13 (Anthony McLean)

A search for missing girl takes a deadly turn when officer Anthony McLean, confronts a criminal who will stop at nothing to avoid jail time.

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-77

Chasing Ghosts (Linda Marie Thies)

A rookie investigator faces the brutal homicide of a young Jane Doe. But the answer to who killed Linda Marie Thies literally walks through the station door.

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-76

Forever Mother’s Day (Rosemary Denis)

Rosemary Denis' fatal accident forces her daughter to suspect a close loved one... A case that truly tests family bonds.

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-75

Jistis Bondye (Altidor Family)

Altidor Family are massacred inside their home. And, the killer leaves behind a handwritten message on the wall. Telltale clue or diversion tactic?

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-74

Marion’s Legacy – Part 2 (Marion Fye)

Nothing is as it seems: A homicide victim spotted alive, an informant with ulterior motives, and a woman.

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-73

Marion’s Legacy (Marion Fye)

In the heart of D.C., a family pleads to solve a Marion Fye murder. Investigators have a possible crime scene and a suspect.

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-72

N.C.I.S. (Pamela Ann Kimbrue)

Just before Pamela Ann Kimbrue is transferred overseas, an enlisted sailor disappears during her normal work routine.

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-71

The 50-Year Investigation (Maureen Brubaker Farley)

A 17-year-old’s dead body is found posed near a ravine. It took 50 years, a relentless detective and a family member to unravel who killed her.

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-70

Buried in the Basement (Mark Koster)

A new homeowner discovers a missing man’s body in the house. A cryptic note and a Pomeranian dog send investigators on a cross-country hunt.

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-69

Southwest Terror: 2011 (Modesta and Liz Lowe)

A violent offender strikes again. And his trial pits him against his abductee from decades past, Liz Lowe.

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-68

Southwest Terror: 1982 (Liz Lowe)

After moving to Houston for fun and freedom, Liz Lowe survives the darkest night of her life. But after telling the police, she discovers she’s not alone.

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-67

Highway Homicide (Joseph “Jody” Wilder)

Would the contents of a briefcase be the motive of a roadside shooting? How would it lead investigators to uncovering the identity of their killer?

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-66

“I Definitely Did It” – Part 2 (Vilet Torrez)

In part two of Vilet Torrez's story...miles of swamps and muck may turn out to be the watery grave of a missing mother.

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-65

“I Definitely Did It” (Vilet Torrez)

A failing marriage leads to obsession, but did it also lead to murder? Four little words in a peculiar 911 call immediately launches the hunt.

Episodic_Website_Episode-64

Packed Away (Daniel Burroughs)

A dad with a history of disappearing vanishes once again. Where Daniel Burroughs was finally found stunned every investigator and family member.

Episodic_Website_Episode-63

Cross-State Crime Spree (Ed Martin, Lonette Keehner)

An 84-year-old woman bound inside her home. Her husband: missing. And, a manhunt stretching over Montana and Idaho.

Episodic_Website_Episode-62

Be Best (Wayne Best)

Shots fired in the dead of night…a house set ablaze…a young man almost run over…and wild rumors swirling in the community.

Episodic_Website_Episode-61

Where’s My Lisa? (Lisa Weaver)

Lisa Weaver goes for a walk on Christmas Eve, but never returns home. Police question a mystery man she met through work.

Episodic_Website_Episode-60

New Year’s Day (Mary Greco)

An 82-year-old nun was found dead inside her home on New Year’s Day. Did her faith play into motive or was this a truly random attack?

Episodic_Website_Episode-59

A Dad Like Santa (Steven Gerecke)

Albuquerque, New Mexico. One night. Multiple crimes. Would the homicide of a beloved bartender, Steven Gerecke, be connected to the rest?

Episodic_Website_Episode-58

Island Intruders (Brian Simpson)

A break-in. Brian Simpson dead inside his home. A true who-done-it left a beach town on edge, waiting and hoping the killers would be caught.

Episodic_Website_Episode-57

Escape from Dearman (Shannon Randall, Joseph Turner, Robert Brown, Chelsea Reed, Justin Reed)

The events depicted in horror movies are meant to live only on screen. In this case, the horrors that occurred in one Alabama house were all too real.

Episodic_Website_Episode-56

If the Shoe Fits – Part 2 (Suzanne Nauman & Phyllis Harvey)

For decades, the homicides of Suzanne Nauman and Phyllis Harvey go unsolved. The clue to solving these cases was right in front of investigators.

Episodic_Website_Episode-55

If the Shoe Fits – Part 1 (Suzanne Nauman)

A troubled 17-year old girl, Suzanne Nauman, was strangled with a shoelace. Was her killer a stranger or an obsessive boyfriend?

Episodic_Website_Episode-54

Urban Legend (Gregory Ross)

A brutal homicide of Gregory Ross in a basement strikes fear in the neighborhood. Sometimes it’s not the ‘by Who’ that’s the main mystery.

Episodic_Website_Episode-53

Bad Times at the Cozy Inn (Earl Marshall)

The Cozy is the restaurant where everybody knows your name. But the identity of who shot owner, Earl Marshall, stumped investigators for decades.

Episodic_Website_Episode-52

Labor Day Murder (Joshua Duncan)

A gruesome murder of Joshua Duncan leads detectives to uncover a repeat offender...someone who was hiding in plain sight.

Episodic_Website_Episode-51

Swapping Ghost Stories (Barbara Hackmann Taylor)

Halloween is known for ghosts and goblins, but in this case, it helped find an answer to a tragic mystery.

Episodic_Website_Episode-50

x4

Two women murdered hours apart and a community on high alert. But, an unsolved double homicide from years before gives the clue needed to solve them all.

Episodic_Website_Episode-49

A Cement Tomb

A family go-karting at an abandoned factory site finds a skeletal hand. Before investigators can find the killer, they have to figure out who was killed.

Episodic_Website_Episode-48

Unpacking a Disappearance

When Joanna Rogers' body is found in a suitcase in a landfill, investigators uncover an unassuming killer.

Episodic_Website_Episode-47

In the Cemetery

A young college student, Brook Baker, is murdered, sending shockwaves through the community making investigators question if a serial killer is loose.

Episodic_Website_Episode-46

NYC’s Only Homicide on 9/11

A young college student, Brook Baker, is murdered, sending shockwaves through the community making investigators question if a serial killer is loose.

Episodic_Website_Episode-45

137F Strikes Again

A young college student, Brook Baker, is murdered, sending shockwaves through the community making investigators question if a serial killer is loose.

Episodic_Website_Episode-44

137F

A young college student, Brook Baker, is murdered, sending shockwaves through the community making investigators question if a serial killer is loose.

Episodic_Website_Episode-43

A Model Mother

The body of Karyn Slover disturbingly turns up in a lake. While archeology helps, DNA from the unlikeliest of sources help find her killer.

Episodic_Website_Episode-42

Evil Eye

Voodoo dolls, candles and a hit list. Will these items answer the questions of who killed a young couple in their home, and why?

Episodic_Website_Episode-41

On Base

Will the results of a computer search conducted on a military base, turn up evidence that leads to a hunt for a sadistic killer?

Episodic_Website_Episode-40

At the Mall

An object found at the bottom of a lake may be investigators’ best chance of solving the brutal homicide of Kim Montelaro.

Episodic_Website_Episode-39

Alibee

Charles Butler doesn’t show up for lunch with his daughter. She knows something is very wrong, but will anyone listen?

Episodic_Website_Episode-38

Lie or Die – Part 2

Murder, another murder, and a hand on a shoulder. How these 3 things intersect and how the tangled web was unwoven hits at the heart of our justice system.

Episodic_Website_Episode-37

Lie or Die – Part 1

Murder, another murder, and a hand on a shoulder. How these 3 things intersect and how the tangled web was unwoven hits at the heart of our justice system.

Episodic_Website_Episode-36

8-Week Marriage

A cord left wrapped in a dead man’s hands. Michael Forbes was killed with it, by his wife. Justified or homicide?

Episodic_Website_Episode-35

Death Pact

Anita Lopez Keen disappears after a day of boating. The mystery remains unsolved for years until a strange phone call is received.

Episodic_Website_Episode-34

On the Road Again

Walter Renz and Linda Buckner live life on the move - is it wanderlust or something more sinister?

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-33

Knock, Knock

A back porch, a container and two friends hold the answer to Carolyn Jasnen's murderous mystery. The truth lies with one of them, but who?

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-32

On the Back Porch

A back porch, a container and two friends hold the answer to Carolyn Jasnen's murderous mystery. The truth lies with one of them, but who?

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-31

Heading West

Brenda Gerow rides off into the sunset, heading west with her boyfriend. She mails her brother a gift and says I’ll be back, but never returns.

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-30

Desi’s Army

A mom’s search for her daughter, Desirea Ferris, leads her to water, cement barrels, trap houses and more …

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-29

Needle in a Needle Stack – Part 2

Will Carter is shot and killed by his on-again, off-again girlfriend, who claims she was justified, fending off an attack after years of abuse.

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-28

Needle in a Needle Stack – Part 1

Will Carter is shot and killed by his on-again, off-again girlfriend, who claims she was justified, fending off an attack after years of abuse.

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-27

Toxic Web of Lies

Will Carter is shot and killed by his on-again, off-again girlfriend, who claims she was justified, fending off an attack after years of abuse.

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-26

Killer on the Line

A young, soon-to-be mom goes to a wedding with a friend and ends up dead. A 911 call reports the murder and leads this case down a darker road than anyone imagined.

Anatomy-of-Murder-Episode-25

Up in Smoke

Within days, two men separately disappear. Did their personal struggles catch up with them or was it something much, much worse?

Anatomy-of-Murder_Episode-24

Apartment #13

A man murdered inside his own home. Would an everyday hand towel be the thing that helps police finally answer the question: was this a robbery gone wrong or something much more personal?

Anatomy-of-Murder_Episode-23

Please Forgive Me

A 25-year-old young woman goes missing. Her family has every reason to believe that the person responsible is someone very close to home.

Anatomy-of-Murder_Bonus-Ep

Bonus Episode: Murder in the Mountains Update

A breaking update in the case involving the 1982 murders of Annette Schnee and Bobbi Jo Oberholzer. A major development in this 39-year-old unsolved, double homicide case.

Anatomy-of-Murder_Episode-22

No Way Out

A double homicide inside an auto dealership … just one part of a killing rampage. How investigators solved it, was completely unexpected.

Anatomy-of-Murder_Episode-21

Sail Away – Part 2

Boat shows, a missing woman and red flags everywhere you look. Did she leave her husband and head to the Caribbean to be with another man? Or … she’s gone, and the truth is something much worse?

Anatomy-of-Murder_Episode-20

Sail Away – Part 1

Boat shows, a missing woman and red flags everywhere you look. Did she leave her husband and head to the Caribbean to be with another man?

Anatomy-of-Murder_Episode-19

A Bridge to Murder

A missing daughter. A mother’s intuition leads her search to a local bridge. She finds her daughter’s body, and soon becomes … the #1 suspect. Right or dead wrong?

Anatomy-of-Murder_Episode-18

Stranger Danger

A 12-year-old girl left home to take a bike ride. Only her bike was found later that day. Days later, the unthinkable was discovered.

Anatomy-of-Murder_Episode-17

New Year’s Eve

New Year’s Eve turns to tragedy. A young man is murdered and his killer spends the next 16 years on the run.

Anatomy-of-Murder_Episode-16

Top Down, Driving the Highway

Off to LA in a VW Bug. In pursuit of her dream, a young woman heads from Oklahoma to LA, driving her blue convertible Bug. Will it be that very same car that will later be needed to help solve her murder?

Anatomy-of-Murder_Episode-15

A Deal to Die For

A specialty car and motorcycle-loving couple disappear. Did they take off for life on the road or did their disappearance signify something much darker?

Anatomy-of-Murder_Episode-14

We Leave You Our Deaths

3 young women, all friends, found dead in a park. A license plate, a ruse, and a federal sting.

Anatomy-of-Murder_Episode-13

Who Murdered Angela?

A young mom and her 6-month-old disappear in the middle of the day. A package left on the porch answers one question but there are still many more.

Anatomy-of-Murder_Episode-12

Where’s Tracey?

Cars, blood and broken glass. Two young women missing. One found. One not. 39 potential suspects widdled down to one.

Anatomy-of-Murder_Episode-11

What a Long, Strange Trip It’s Been – Part 2

Chippewa Falls, Wisconsin. A wife is found dead in the garage by her husband. The trial for her murder takes an unexpected turn, and leads a young prosecutor on a virtual road-trip.

Anatomy-of-Murder_Episode-10

What a Long, Strange Trip It’s Been – Part 1

Chippewa Falls, Wisconsin. A wife is found dead in the garage by her husband. The trial for her murder takes an unexpected turn, and leads a young prosecutor on a virtual road-trip.

Anatomy-of-Murder_Episode-9

A Single Drop of Blood

A woman is viciously attacked in her home, leading investigators on a desperate search for answers. Could a small piece of glass hold the key?

Anatomy-of-Murder_Episode-8

Murder in the Mountains

A young woman is murdered in the mountains of Breckenridge, Colorado. And the case still looms over this ski town.

Anatomy-of-Murder_Episode-7

You’ve Got Mail

Cari Farver disappeared, but emails and texts from her continued to litter the inbox of the last man in her life. But her mother says it’s not her.

Anatomy-of-Murder_Episode-6

Military, Secrets and Lies

Murder, suicide and an investigation that spanned over 2,000 miles.

Anatomy-of-Murder_Episode-5

Desert of Death

When young women started to disappear in El Paso, TX, one mother put the community in motion to stop a serial killer before he struck again.

Anatomy-of-Murder_Episode-4

The Evil That Lurks

Two women: one dead and the other endured the unthinkable. This is a case that we lost sleep over.

Anatomy-of-Murder_Episode-3

I Wish You’d Burn

Teenage drama turns deadly when 15-year-old, Katie Hamlin, disappears after a night out with friends.

Anatomy-of-Murder-_-Ep2

Truth or Dare?

A shooter ambushes a young father in front of his home. The man in custody confesses, almost too easily.

Anatomy-of-Murder-_-Ep1

Little Girl Turned Sleuth

A 4-year-old girl finds her single mom murdered. 46 years later, that same little girl helped catch the killer.

Loading...