In this Indiana town, murders are rare, but rumors run rampant. A sheriff nearing retirement sifts through leads to solve a 41-year-old case.
Episode Info

Sarah Jeanette Benson
Photo Courtesy of WBIW News

Sarah Jeanette Benson
Photo Courtesy of of Sullivan County Sheriff’s Office

Sarah Jeanette Benson
Photo Courtesy of of Sullivan County Sheriff’s Office

Crime Scene
Photo Courtesy of of Sullivan County Sheriff’s Office

Crime Scene
Photo Courtesy of of Sullivan County Sheriff’s Office

Crime Scene
Photo Courtesy of of Sullivan County Sheriff’s Office

Crime Scene
Photo Courtesy of of Sullivan County Sheriff’s Office

Crime Scene
Photo Courtesy of of Sullivan County Sheriff’s Office